Customer Experience Conundrum – The Fine Line Between Self-service and Customer Service

Self-service, when it works, it is a wonderful thing: online shopping when insomnia strikes, checking in for your flight on the way to the airport, using your phone to hail a ride downtown. However, there are still plenty of occasions when customers really do need to speak to a human to get something accomplished.

A recent experience has left me to wonder, have the scales tipped so far toward automation and self-service that when a human interaction is needed, the experience suffers?

I had an issue with updating information in a customer loyalty program of all things and, unfortunately for me, this could not be resolved online due to the circuitous challenge of a forgotten password and an ancient email address.

To fix the problem I needed to speak to a human. I called the organization only to learn that my wait time for a live customer service rep in the loyalty program would be between 32 and 57 minutes. Finally, after listening to muzak for 90 minutes, a representative came on the line, apologized for the wait, listened to my quandary and then went off to investigate what could be done. He popped on the line one more time to assure me that he had not disappeared, and I was back on hold.

He returned, with a solution! However, when he suggested that I could go online, fill in a form, and provide a copy of a photo ID, and then get a response in 24 hours, I was less than thrilled. I explained that waiting nearly 2 hours to hear this was unacceptable. The supervisor who was brought in quickly updated my information and waited on the line with me as I reset the password. I was left wondering, was this process not known by the first representative I spoke to?

As a consumer, I understand the demand for self-service, the need for immediate gratification, and the faster the better mentality. But in efforts to address that need, has good old-fashioned customer service suffered? Has automation and call center assistance with chatbots negated the need for a well-staffed team of people to answer the phone in a timely manner and help another human with their problem?

In our work with CIOs and CMOs, we have discussed both sides of the coin, and I don’t think there is a one size fits all answer, but I do believe there needs to be a balance of technology and human intervention to show that companies understand the challenge, keep customers engaged, and ensure that their best advocates don’t turn to the competition.

Related Stories

Mastering Executive Engagement
What’s Holding You Back?

Posted on 01.10.2019 by in Engagement Strategy

Strong relationships with your c-level customers can accelerate change, uncover opportunities, and strengthen your company’s position. What keeps B2Bs from earning those relationships—and realizing their value? We’ve identified 10 common—but surmountable—barriers that hold B2Bs back.

Continue Reading »

Getting to a Customer Engagement Mindset

Posted on 12.3.2018 by in Engagement Strategy

Many marketers are stuck in an activity mindset, focused more on the event calendar and the client reference database than strategic conversations with customers. In contrast, an engagement mindset creates a strategy focused from the outside-in rather than from the  

Continue Reading »

All is Not Lost for Brick and Mortar in the Digital Age of Shopping

Posted on 11.28.2018 by in Engagement Strategy

A couple of years ago, I ventured out on Black Friday to find uncrowded stores, likely due to technology and the shift in the way consumers buy products. And last year on Thanksgiving night, I decided to switch it up  

Continue Reading »

From Seller to Advisor: Engage Your Customers to Help You Stop Pitching

Posted on 11.11.2018 by in Engagement Strategy, Featured

At the 2015 ITSMA annual conference, we considered, “If it is all about the customer experience, why are we still pitching?” We share the key takeaways from our discussion with Janis Fratamico, Director, Relationship Marketing at Bloomberg and David Coates,  

Continue Reading »


Customer Advisory Boards

An advisory board is a powerful engine of engagement, insight, and business transformation. Make the most of yours.

A Board Success Factor: Business and Industry Expertise » Advisory Boards: How to Extend the Value »

Learn More »

Engagement Strategy

Like any good relationship, customer engagement is a long-term, reciprocal effort. When done well, meaningful engagement leads to better business results, faster.

Engage Your Customers to Help You Stop Pitching » Getting to a Customer Engagement Mindset »

Learn More »

Understanding the C-Suite

Want to improve your standing with your C-suite customers? Deliver what executives want: ideas, inspiration, innovation, influence.

C-Suite Insight: Digital Disruption » Looking to Engage Executives? First, Understand What They Want »

Learn More »